
Former bodybuilder and American Gladiator Shelley Beattie. Photo Credit: HBO SIREN: THE VOICES OF SHELLEY BEATTIE
Reel Respect: Siren, and the Line Between Truth and Harm
First Reaction to Siren: The Voices of Shelley Beattie
I’ve spent weeks deciding how to write this piece. The documentary I watched last month moved me, and it also made me question how I cover women’s sports. Before I explain why, a content note: this story includes drug use, self-harm, mental illness, and sexual assault.
Resources:
988 Suicide & Crisis Lifeline - call or text 988
RAINN - (800) 656-4673
I consider myself an advocate for women. I also value the truth, even when it’s complicated, and I believe there is a delicate line between telling true stories and perpetuating harm. Holding both of those, it took me time to come back to Reel Respect.
Let me rewind. The idea for this series started while I was preparing to interview Olympian and filmmaker Mary Mazzio. Her latest film, Mighty Mary, follows the first (mostly, more on that in another post) all-women crew to compete in the America’s Cup. Before that interview, I didn’t even know what the America’s Cup was.
I loved learning about the crew, and I was surprised to find a familiar name in that history. I grew up watching American Gladiators, and Siren was a favorite of mine. What I didn’t know is that Siren, born Shelley Beattie, was deaf.
Mazzio’s film names Beattie’s strength as a major asset while acknowledging the challenges of communication. It’s a brief part of the story, but a significant one. I’ll go deeper on Mighty Mary later in this series. For now, you can watch my interview with Mazzio ⬇️
A few weeks later, while researching more women’s sports documentaries, I found Siren: The Voices of Shelley Beattie. I knew Beattie died in 2008 and little else, so I pressed play without doing additional research.
There is a lot I appreciated about Irene Taylor’s film, and I plan to give it a full review. Today, though, I want to talk about something that didn’t come up in the version of Mazzio’s film I watched. According to Taylor’s documentary, Beattie was removed from the America’s Cup team after she sexually assaulted a woman at a team event.
To know Shelley you need to know both sides of her.
I was heartbroken for that woman. I was also shocked by the detail, and curious by the realization that it was not part of the Mighty Mary story I watched.
I don’t believe we should excuse acts of harm. Too many people carry the shame of abuse they survived, and I’m not sure our society knows how to talk about abuse from the perspective of the person who caused the harm.
On one hand, the answer seems obvious. Where is the line between telling the truth and centering the abuser? Should there be a line at all?
On the other hand, I believe a healthier society requires presenting facts as objectively as we can and giving people room to work through painful, complicated situations.
I’ll be honest: I’m not comfortable with this topic. Taylor’s film made me think about many things, but none more than this: how do we stand with survivors of violence while still telling a complete story?
I don’t see the film as a redemption arc for Beattie. I’m still wary of addressing her story so early in the Reel Respect series, and I tried to move on to other documentaries on our list. But the film, and what it asked of me as a woman, a human, and a journalist, stayed with me. I’m grateful for that. It’s what storytelling is for.
So although I’m not sure yet how to write a full review of Siren, I wonder if this is exactly what a film club is for.
Naming what Beattie did to a woman she worked closely with opens the door to bigger questions about her upbringing, her mental health (another significant thread in Taylor’s film), and ultimately her legacy. Much of the film disturbed me, but not enough to keep me from sharing my analysis, even while I’m still processing.
I don’t expect every Reel Respect review to be this heavy, but I’m glad this challenge came early. Not every story about women in sports will be inspiring or uplifting, and I’m committed to telling stories where sport and society meet. Taylor’s film, which streams on HBO Max, was an early test of that commitment.
Would I recommend it? Yes, for viewers who want a compelling story about women in all their complexity. I don’t regret going in with so little knowledge, but I hope this note helps our WBB Roundup readers decide how to take care of themselves before they watch.
This was a hard one to write, and I’m glad I put my raw thoughts down. Eventually, I’d love to continue this conversation with you, our readers, and with other experts: how do we advocate for women without leaving out the darker parts of the human experience?
Resources:
988 Suicide & Crisis Lifeline - call or text 988
RAINN - (800) 656-4673

Listen to the audio version of today’s newsletter below.

THE EXTRA POSSESSION
Reel Respect: Advocacy, Accountability, and a Film That Won’t Leave Me Alone
If you’re interested in more women’s sports documentaries, check out our Reel Respect list. We are constantly growing our list, so feel free to reach out with films you’d like to see added to the list.
Every month, Erica will write a review of one of the films and starting in 2027, we will launch special watch-alongs or conversations with filmmakers, athletes, and other special guests to discuss storytelling in women’s sports.
📰 WHAT WE’RE READING
We’ve remixed this section for our Reel Respect series. Here are other reviews of ‘Siren: The Voices of Shelley Beattie’:
📲 STAY CONNECTED!
If you enjoyed this newsletter, consider subscribing to receive the latest updates from Black Rosie Media directly in your inbox—it's completely FREE!
Subscribers will gain access to the Black Rosie Media Slack Channel to interact directly with our contributors, participate in game-day chats, and much more!


